Fad Diets vs. Real Life: Why Quick Fixes Don’t Work Well for Women in Perimenopause

Let’s be honest—most of us have tried some version of a fad diet. Whether it’s cutting out carbs completely, drinking green juices for a week straight, or eating tiny meals that leave you starving by 3 PM, we’ve all been there. And if you’re over 40, you’ve probably noticed these “quick fixes” just don’t work like they used to. It’s not because you’re doing something wrong—it’s because your body is changing, and fad diets aren’t built for real life or what’s happening in your biology.

How Perimenopause and Menopause Affect Weight Loss

If you’ve hit your 40s and feel like your body has flipped a switch, you’re not imagining it. Hormonal changes during perimenopause and menopause completely shift how your body stores fat, uses energy, and even how you feel about food.

Here's what's happening:

1. Hormonal Shifts Change Fat Storage.

As estrogen levels drop, your body naturally starts storing more fat around your middle. This is visceral fat, and it’s more than just annoying—it’s linked to things like diabetes and heart disease.

2. Your Metabolism Slows Down.

Aging lowers your metabolic rate, meaning you’re burning fewer calories even when you’re just sitting there. Add in a loss of muscle mass (if you’re not strength training), and it can feel impossible to lose weight.

3. Insulin Resistance Can Creep In.

Your body doesn’t process sugar as well as it used to, so carbs and sweets hit harder, leading to blood sugar swings and more fat storage.

4. Stress and Sleep Play a Bigger Role.

High stress from work, family, or just life raises cortisol, which makes your body hold onto fat—especially in your belly. If you’re not sleeping well (thanks, hormones), that stress-fat cycle only gets worse.

These changes can feel frustrating, but they don’t mean you’re stuck. It just means the old tricks won’t work anymore.

Why Don’t Fad Diets Work After 40?

Fad diets promise quick results, but they don’t care about your hormones, your busy life, or what it’s actually like to be a woman in your 40s trying to juggle everything. Here’s why they let us down:

1. They Don’t Address Hormones.

Most fad diets are all about slashing calories or cutting out food groups. For women over 40, that’s a disaster. Extreme calorie-cutting spikes your cortisol, and ignoring carbs completely messes with your energy and mood.

2. They’re Too Restrictive.

No carbs, no sugar, no joy? That’s not sustainable when you have birthday parties, work lunches, or a family to feed. Life doesn’t stop just because you’re trying to lose weight.

3. They Burn Muscle Instead of Fat.

Fad diets focus on quick weight loss, which usually means losing water weight and muscle—things you need to keep your metabolism running.

4. They Ignore That Everyone Is Different.

What works for a 25-year-old fitness influencer won’t work for you, because your body, hormones, and lifestyle are completely different.

The Real-Life Alternative: A Sustainable Approach That Works

So, what does work? The answer isn’t sexy, but it is life-changing: small, realistic changes that fit your life and respect what’s happening in your body.

Here’s what that looks like:

1. Eat in a Way That Balances Hormones.

Instead of starving yourself, focus on adding foods that work with your body. Build meals around protein (to keep muscle and metabolism strong), healthy fats (to support your hormones), and fiber (to keep you full and your digestion happy).

2. Make Small Changes That Stick.

You don’t need to overhaul your entire life overnight. Start small—like adding more protein to breakfast or taking a 10-minute walk after lunch. These are the kinds of changes you can actually keep up long term. Find personalized strategies that work for you.

3. Focus on Feeling Good First.

The goal isn’t just to lose weight—it’s to feel better in your body, have more energy, and know that you’re taking care of yourself in a way that works.

Strategies for Long-Term Success

Building healthy habits that last is all about keeping it simple and doable. Here are three ways to set yourself up for success:

1. Build Muscle.

Lifting weights isn’t just for bodybuilders. As we age, strength training becomes essential for keeping your metabolism humming and your body strong.  Learn more about what you need to build muscle and how it impacts weight loss here.

2. Move More Throughout Your Day.

You don’t need to spend hours in the gym. NEAT (Non-Exercise Activity Thermogenesis) is just a fancy way of saying “move more.” Take the stairs, park farther away, stand up while you work—these little things add up.

3. Plan Balanced Protein + Nutrient Rich Meals That Work for You.

Instead of following rigid meal plans, focus on simple, balanced meals that are easy to make and satisfying. Think grilled chicken, roasted veggies, and a healthy fat like avocado or olive oil. Sprinkle in the fun stuff here and there, because life is meant to be lived. All while keeping the main things like protein, fiber and healthy carbs the main thing.

You Can Do This

The truth is, quick fixes don’t work because they’re not designed for real women with real lives. But a sustainable approach—one that’s realistic, rooted in biology, and built around small changes—does work. You don’t have to do it all at once, and you definitely don’t have to do it alone.

If you’re ready to feel better, lose weight, and finally have a plan that works for you, let’s figure it out together. Visit Mila.fit to learn how to make it happen.

Who do you want to share this with? Who can you help?